Sammy's Italian Restaurant & Pizza
Authentic New York-style pizza and Italian favorites in Ocala since 1997
Brooklyn Roots, Ocala Heart
When Sammy packed up his pizza peels and moved from Brooklyn to Ocala in 1997, he brought with him the one thing that would define his new chapter in Florida: the art of authentic New York-style pizza. After years of owning and operating pizzerias across Brooklyn, Sammy saw an opportunity to introduce real New York pizza to the SR 200 corridor. Nearly three decades later, Sammy's Italian Restaurant and Pizza has become one of the most trusted names in Italian food in Marion County.
The pizza at Sammy's is the anchor of the menu. Each pie starts with hand-tossed dough that bakes into an airy, flaky crust, the hallmark of true New York-style pizza. The sauce is made from fresh ingredients using family recipes that Sammy perfected during his years in Brooklyn. Whether you order a classic cheese slice, a loaded Sicilian, or a white pizza, the quality is consistent and unmistakably authentic. It's the kind of pizza that New York transplants recognize immediately and that converts everyone else.
Beyond pizza, the menu at Sammy's covers the full range of Italian-American comfort food. Lasagna, baked ziti, spaghetti and meatballs, and ravioli are all prepared fresh daily. Calzones and stromboli come stuffed with your choice of fillings. Calamari, garlic knots, and pasta fagioli soup start the meal right, and the Greek salad is a longtime customer favorite. Sammy's son Paulie has worked alongside his father since childhood, learning every technique and recipe firsthand, ensuring the family tradition carries forward.
With over 1,500 Google reviews averaging 4.5 stars, Sammy's reputation speaks for itself. Customers consistently praise the family-like hospitality, noting that the staff treats every guest like a regular. The restaurant offers dine-in, takeout, delivery, and catering, with online ordering available through their website. For anyone along the SR 200 corridor looking for Italian food that goes beyond the chain experience, Sammy's delivers exactly what its Brooklyn origins promise: quality, flavor, and heart in every dish.
Since 1997
Nearly three decades of serving authentic Italian food on SR 200. Sammy's has stood the test of time through quality and consistency.
Brooklyn Recipes
Family recipes from Sammy's Brooklyn pizzerias. Authentic New York-style pizza with hand-tossed dough and fresh sauce.
Family-Owned
Sammy and his son Paulie run the restaurant together. The family atmosphere extends to how they treat every guest who walks through the door.
Made Fresh Daily
Every dish is prepared fresh. From pizza dough to pasta sauce, Sammy's never cuts corners on quality or freshness.
4.5-Star Average
Over 1,500 Google reviews with a 4.5-star average. One of the highest-rated Italian restaurants on the SR 200 corridor.
Catering & Delivery
Dine-in, takeout, delivery, and full catering services. Online ordering available through their website for fast, easy ordering.
Menu Highlights
New York-Style Pizza
Hand-tossed dough with fresh sauce and quality toppings. Classic, Sicilian, and white pizza varieties, all made from Brooklyn family recipes.
Pasta Classics
Lasagna, baked ziti, spaghetti and meatballs, and ravioli prepared fresh daily with house-made sauces.
Calzones & Stromboli
Stuffed with your choice of fillings and baked to golden perfection. Served with marinara for dipping.
Calamari & Garlic Knots
Crispy fried calamari and warm garlic knots make the perfect starters. Pair with pasta fagioli soup for a complete Italian experience.
Wings & Seafood
Wings, shrimp dishes, and other options round out a menu that goes well beyond pizza and pasta.
Monday Special
Spaghetti with Meatballs for $8.99 on Mondays. A weekly deal that keeps regulars coming back to start the week right.
Hours & Contact Information
Business Hours
Monday - Thursday: 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM - 8:30 PM
Sunday: Closed
Get In Touch
Frequently Asked Questions
Where is Sammy's Italian Restaurant in Ocala?
Sammy's Italian Restaurant and Pizza is located at 6106 SW State Road 200 in Ocala, Florida 34476. It's situated along the busy SR 200 corridor, easily accessible from the surrounding communities of SW Ocala and the On Top of the World area.
What are Sammy's Italian hours?
Sammy's is open Monday through Thursday from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM, Friday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 8:30 PM. The restaurant is closed on Sundays.
Does Sammy's make real New York-style pizza?
Yes! Sammy, the founder, moved to Florida from Brooklyn, New York, where he had owned and operated multiple pizzerias. He brought his authentic New York pizza-making techniques to Ocala in 1997, and the tradition continues with his son Paulie. The pizza features an airy, flaky crust and sauce made from fresh ingredients using family recipes.
Does Sammy's offer delivery?
Yes, Sammy's Italian offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery. You can order directly from the restaurant by calling (352) 861-2828 or through their website at sammysitalianrestaurants.com for convenient online ordering.
Does Sammy's have gluten-free options?
Yes, Sammy's Italian offers gluten-free options on their menu. Contact the restaurant for current availability and specifics about their gluten-free preparations.
Does Sammy's cater events?
Yes, Sammy's Italian provides catering services for events, parties, and gatherings. From pizza trays to full Italian catering spreads, they can accommodate a range of event sizes. Call (352) 861-2828 to discuss catering options.
How long has Sammy's been in Ocala?
Sammy's Italian Restaurant was established in 1997, making it a fixture on the SR 200 corridor for nearly three decades. Sammy brought his Brooklyn pizza-making skills to Ocala, and his son Paulie grew up in the business learning every aspect of Italian cooking alongside his father.
Does Sammy's have other locations?
Yes, in addition to the original Ocala location on SR 200, Sammy's has a second location in Wildwood, Florida. Both locations maintain the same family recipes and commitment to authentic New York-style pizza and Italian cooking.
Craving Real New York Pizza?
Visit Sammy's Italian on SR 200 for authentic Brooklyn-style pizza and Italian favorites, served with family hospitality since 1997.